The Faculty of Law at Universitas Diponegoro once again held the Undip Global Classroom (UGC) on Tuesday, May 19, 2026, featuring Assoc. Prof. João Ilhão Moreira, from the Faculty of Law at the University of Macau, is the main speaker. Themed “The Regulation of International Commercial Arbitration,” this activity was part of the Arbitration Law course and was attended by students of the Faculty of Law at Universitas Diponegoro. The academic discussion was enriched by responses from Ardina Nur Amalia, S.H., M.H., as the discussant.
In her presentation, Prof. Moreira encouraged participants to view international arbitration not merely as a dispute-resolution mechanism but also as a profession with unique characteristics compared to other legal professions. She began the discussion with two fundamental questions: whether arbitration regulations truly serve the interests of the parties and society, and to what extent the arbitration community shapes and influences applicable regulations. According to him, these two questions are crucial for understanding the development of international arbitration amidst the increasingly complex nature of cross-border trade relations.
Prof. Moreira then explained the concept of profession through two main approaches: the functionalist and neo-Weberian perspectives. In the functionalist approach, a profession gains special status because it possesses complex knowledge, adheres to ethical standards, undergoes specialized education, and is expected to act in the public interest. Conversely, the neo-Weberian approach views professions as the result of professionalization, namely, a group’s efforts to create professional boundaries through education, licensing, regulation, and specific exclusivity mechanisms.
He further explained that international arbitrators do not fully fulfill the characteristics of a profession as understood in either approach. On the one hand, arbitrators are generally highly educated legal professionals with extensive international networks and are trusted to perform functions in the public interest. However, on the other hand, the arbitration profession does not require special licensing, lacks uniform formal educational requirements, and is more regulated by soft law than by binding legal regulations. These conditions make arbitration a profession that develops differently from traditional legal professions such as judges, advocates, and notaries.
According to Prof. Moreira, most arbitrators do not practice arbitration as their primary profession. Many arbitrators maintain careers as advocates, academics, or other legal professionals, while assignments as arbitrators are undertaken in parallel or at a later stage in their careers. The high demand for professional experience influences this phenomenon, the importance of reputation in securing appointments as arbitrators, and the nature of the international arbitration market, which relies heavily on professional networks and the parties’ trust.
He also explained that regulations for arbitrators also differ from those for other professions. While various arbitration associations, institutions, and practitioner communities actively develop ethical guidelines and standards of practice, these regulations generally do not aim to create a monopoly over the profession or restrict the entry of new players into the arbitration market. Instead, one principle that remains intact in international arbitration is party autonomy, namely the parties’ freedom to choose the arbitrator they deem most appropriate to resolve the dispute. According to Prof. Moreira, this principle is one of the key differences between arbitration and other, more closed professions.
In the discussion session, Ardina Nur Amalia, S.H., M.H., connected these concepts to the practice of commercial arbitration in Indonesia, including the challenges of strengthening national arbitration institutions, the application of the principles of arbitrator independence and impartiality, and developments in international business dispute resolution, which are increasingly influenced by the globalization of trade and technological advancements. The students’ enthusiasm was evident in the questions they asked about arbitrator ethical standards, the mechanism for arbitrator appointment, and the prospects for arbitration as a career option in law. Through the Undip Global Classroom, students gained a comparative perspective on the development of international arbitration regulations. They understood that the effectiveness of the arbitration system is determined not only by applicable legal regulations but also by the integrity, independence, and professionalism of the arbitrators.