Universitas Diponegoro Faculty of Law again held Undip Global Classroom (UGC) activities, featuring Prof. Dr. Albertjan Tollenaar, LL.M., from the University of Groningen as the main speaker. This activity, which was held on April 16, 2026, had the theme “Empirical Legal Research”, with Dr. Afif Mahfud, S.H., M.H., acting as discussant. Based on the material presented, this session provides an in-depth understanding of the importance of empirical research in studying law as a social phenomenon.
In his presentation, Prof. Tollenaar emphasized that law should not only be understood as a collection of norms, regulations, contracts and court decisions, but also as an instrument that influences the behavior of individuals, organizations and social institutions. Therefore, legal research is not enough to answer only questions about what is regulated by law; it also needs to examine how the law is applied, understood, and produces impacts in real life.
This explanation then highlights the basic differences between doctrinal legal research and empirical legal research. Doctrinal research focuses on analyzing legal norms, principles and decisions to answer internal legal problems. In contrast, empirical research seeks to explain behavior, practices, and social structures related to law, thereby enabling researchers to understand how law works in social reality.
Prof. Tollenaar also introduced the concept of law in action, which developed in the traditions of Legal Realism and Law and Society. This approach departs from the understanding that written law (law in the books) is not always identical to the law implemented in practice. Therefore, empirical research is needed to identify gaps between legal norms and their implementation, as well as explain the factors that influence the effectiveness of a policy or regulation.
In this session, participants were introduced to key components of empirical research design, including formulating propositions, using theory, determining units of analysis and testing validity and reliability. Prof. Tollenaar emphasized that good empirical research must connect theoretical concepts with observable facts through measurable indicators. Thus, research not only produces descriptions of phenomena but also provides scientifically justified explanations.
Apart from discussing the conceptual framework, the presenters also explained various methods commonly used in empirical legal research, such as observation, surveys and interviews. Each method has advantages and limitations that need to be considered in light of the research objectives. In practice, the use of multiple methods simultaneously (a multi-method approach) or triangulation is often needed to obtain a more comprehensive picture of a legal phenomenon.
One important point emphasized in the discussion is that empirical research is not intended to replace doctrinal research, but rather to complement it. If doctrinal research aims to answer whether an action is in accordance with the law, empirical research seeks to explain how the law influences people’s behavior and why a policy produces a certain impact. The combination of these two approaches is becoming increasingly important in responding to contemporary legal challenges that are increasingly complex and multidimensional. Through this activity, participants gain a broader understanding of modern legal research methodology and the importance of integrating normative and empirical perspectives to produce research relevant to the development of legal science and the formulation of public policy. This activity also strengthens the Faculty of Law, Universitas Diponegoro’s commitment to fostering students’ research capacity through academic exposure from international experts.